« Stop the presses | Main | WMD, Again »

Fractals

After a hellish, nearly 60 hour work-week, I return with a few links and "shorts."

I hesitate to pick out some interesting posts I've noticed of late while making the rounds of the blogs, because I certainly do not mean to imply that those I won't mention aren't valuable and interesting. It's just that a few dovetail well with what I've been thinking recently - in the hypnagogic and hypnopompic states, if you, like, know what I'm sayin' sayin'.

...

David Adesnik has a strong post at Oxblog which exposes the vacuous soul-searching undertaken by some "liberal hawks" over at TNR in light of the question whether they regretted supporting the invasion of Iraq. Perhaps predictably, most credit their own instincts and intuitions, blaming Bush and Co. for every shattered hope and expectation.

...

Melanie Phillips, at times a Bush critic but never a hysterical Bush hater, outlines an interesting case that Bush was foolish to insist that Turkey be admitted to the EU, since, superficial appearances notwithstanding, Turkey lacks genuine cultural affinity with Europe. I'm not sure if Melanie intended this, but she almost seemed to suggest that Chirac's concerns and her own are isomorphic - whereas I would suspect other raison d'Etat as motivating the French President primarily.

...

Saddam shows a sense of humor? In the BBC write-up on Saddam's court appearance:

'Hearing the charge relating to Halabja, where about 5,000 Kurdish civilians died in a single day, Saddam Hussein said, "Yes, I heard about that."'

..

Thinking about intellectual integrity ... I'm not sure whether or not to see "Fahrenheit 9.11." I find Michael Moore to be a loathsome individual, but that's no refutation of his assertions - he could be right, wholly or in part, for all that. But my aversion to his person makes me hesitate to add to his "war chest," though the cost of not seeing the film will be having a considered opinion about it. But if I do see it, I want my attitude to be such that I'm not in attendance simply in order to be able to attack it, firsthand. You know, have the conclusion first, and subsequently find the "evidence" to fit it - like Moore himself seems to do (I can hear it now: "Like Bush did over Iraq too"!). Until then, I'll give provisional ear to critics whose opinions I respect.

...

A considered, sharp post over at The Stopped Clock relating to music licensing and piracy (one of my pet protests). More broadly I addressed this issue in one of my first blog entries.

...

The redoubtable Roger is really on a roll, ranging across the landscape of philosophy, literature, etc. Good stuff, even though we often disagree.

July 1, 2004 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834205dc953ef00e5501e3e038833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Fractals:

Comments

Paul, thanks for the recommend.
Re Turkey and France, the must read is this analysis of Chirac's main right wing rival, Sarkozy, in the Prospect: http://www.prospect-magazine.co.uk/start.asp?P_Article=12708

The author is a Tory living in France, and his heart is obviously with Sarkozy, who is opposed to Turkey jointing the EU. Myself, I find arguments about Turkish culture being alien to Europe simply astonishing. Turkey has been part of Europe since the fall of Constatinople. The argument from difference of religion is the argument that Bosnia is not part of Europe -- or the argument, made by the Catholic right-wing in the 1900s, that Protestants, and certainly Jews, aren't part of Europe. This mistakes the continual flux of history for some predestined combination of divine features. I don't buy it. Bush should have been a little less hamhanded in his urging, but he's right this time.

Posted by: roger at Jul 5, 2004 1:01:09 PM

Roger,

Thanks for the link (and comment).

I'll check the piece out, which may well address a few preliminary questions I have - I don't really have a dog in this fight - but I'll pose them here too.

What about Czar Nicholas' quip that the Ottoman Empire was the "sick man of Europe"? Imperial disintegration might have been the focus of that jibe, but surely the Islamic pedigree of the Ottoman seat and dominions had some causal relevance (cf. The West and The Rest by Roger Scruton, which makes an interesting case that Islamic lands almost have to be governed imperially).

Isn't "democracy" in modern Turkey different in some essential respects from the variety which animates "Europe" - espec. with respect to the role of the military in safeguarding the regime?

What about Melanie Phillips' point that the issue isn't Islam per se, but rather the ascendancy of Islamism?

Posted by: Paul Craddick at Jul 6, 2004 10:42:14 AM

Thanks for the interesting set of thoughts and the link. I keep thinking about putting together my own thoughts on Moore's movie, but... I think I find the criticism of the film (fair and unfair) more interesting than the film itself. From my perspective, the biggest contribution of the film was giving some screen time to members of the military, wounded veterans, and their families - who have been all-but-shut out of the mainstream media.

Posted by: Aaron at Jul 6, 2004 7:41:04 PM

Turkey's democracy actually parallels, in an uncanny way, Greece's. In fact, I'd say the difference Phillips is talking about is anchored not to Islam so much as to a certain Meditteranean culture, that goes from Portugal to Lebanon.

So the question is: how to proceed from a history of dictatorships? What the EU did for Spain, I think it can do, at least in part, for Turkey. The problem is not Islam, it is that the EU of the 80s, flush with cash, is no longer. The French and the Germans were amazingly generous in their granting of aid to Spain, and to Greece. Just look at Greece just before the expiration of the colonels' power, and Greece now. EU money was a strong driver of that prosperity.

Will it work for Turkey, a much larger country? No. Or at least, not in the same way. But it will help a lot.

Posted by: roger at Jul 7, 2004 6:56:46 PM

Aaron,

I look forward to reading your take on Fahrenheit, should you be inspired to put it in writing.

What commentary has been provided by people in the film that you believe has been missing from mainstream media coverage?

Roger,

What about the matter of Islamism's star being on the ascendant in Turkey?

Posted by: Paul Craddick at Jul 8, 2004 6:03:53 PM