« Res Publica + Publican != Republican | Main | It's about time »

I know how he feels

I'm speaking of the previous potentate of Iraq - or perhaps the still and deservedly future one, de jure, should you subscribe to the view that the invasion of Iraq was "illegal." No, I don't know what it feels like to be dethroned, though I have been knocked off a pedestal a time or two, and have been cut down to size on occasion. Rather, Saddam "underwent an operation to repair a hernia bout 10 days ago," according to this article..

I had a double hernia repair back in early '02 - an experience I'm glad to have long behind me, even though I was fortunate to have it done laproscopically (and thus was up and running again in short order). The surgeon was so proud of his work that he challenged me to do anything I could think of to undo his handiwork. To this day, thankfully, I've been unable to unravel the teflon-like mesh (or whatever it is) that is now part of my innards.

Is it strange that - barring dangerous hernias, which have been know to occur - Saddam might be given a "comfort operation," since he's likely, uh, not to be with us too much longer, by design?!

The case isn't unique to him, of course. One occasionally hears about prison physicians making every effort to keep a death row prisoner alive, preventing Nature from taking the prize that "society" allegedly covets. Or is it simply humane, so long as a prisoner is alive/allowed to live, to minister to his somatic ailments?

It assuredly sticks in the craw of some people that overseeing the punishment of a malefactor entails a reciprocal desideratum of sorts - medical treatment for the criminal - which in many circumstances isn't automatically available to a law-abiding but indigent person. As Nietzsche might ask, a "parable"?

October 12, 2004 | Permalink

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834205dc953ef00e5501e3e218833

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference I know how he feels:

Comments

I've always liked the notion that it would be "cruel and unusual punishment" to execute somebody who is insane - "so let's get a court order, force him to take meds, and make sure he's completely sane when we fry him".

Posted by: Aaron at Oct 13, 2004 3:09:49 PM

I ... know how you feel :)(forgive me!)

Posted by: Paul Craddick at Oct 14, 2004 10:50:37 AM

I think the death penalty itself is cruel and unusual - but if cruel and unusual punishment could be justified in any case, it could be justified in Hussein's case.

That's a judgement call for a democratic Iraq (some day), and it could come down to a question of whether Iraq really wants to go down that road.

Posted by: lenin at Oct 14, 2004 11:44:56 AM

On a serious note ... We're essentially in agreement, lenin. I'm no enthusiast for the death penalty, but there are a few executions at which I definitely won't shed any tears - Saddam's amongst them.

Posted by: Paul Craddick at Oct 14, 2004 2:18:54 PM

On an unserious note.... my late grandfather's preferred commentary on hernia surgeries (and he had three):

There once was a man with a hernia,
Who said to the doctor, "Goldurnia,
When you go down below,
Take it easy and slow,
And don't cut was doesn't concern ya"

Posted by: Aaron at Oct 16, 2004 9:04:36 AM

Ha! Luckily grandpa's concern wasn't à propos to my surgery, since (as I mentioned), I had "keyhole" surgery. Speaking of which - "keyholes" - I didn't drink enough liquids prior to my op. and so had difficulty, uh, micturating, which led to a most unpleasant experience with a strangely enthusiastic nurse ...

Posted by: Paul Craddick at Oct 16, 2004 9:36:19 AM