« Apologies (again) | Main | The Real Chicken Hawks »
Once you've decided ...
Let's say that one has gone on record already and endorsed either Bush or Kerry - given one's "definitive" statement. In what spirit then does one approach intelligent commentators who make a strong case for the opposite? Surely any concession will be qualified with a "but ..." Making one's mind up - which can hardly be avoided - seems to involve a certain amount of stubborness, namely, that which attends a matter which one wishes to have settled.
I've been thinking about this a lot recently, for, I trust, obvious reasons. It came up again this morning, as I noted that Andrew Sullivan had some positive words to say about the Bush endorsement from "Jane Galt." But - and I don't mean this as any kind of atttack on Sullivan; he's just a noteworthy touchstone - surely it's almost inconceivable that he would reverse himself and write a Bush endorsement for TNR to override his recent piece coming out for Kerry.
Yes, the psychology of decision and resolution is quite interesting. As I often do, I think of Nietzsche, whom Freud praised for extraordinary self-insight. I quote Nietzsche a lot here, which might give the misleading impression that I fancy myself a Nietzschean, or buy in to his foundational claims. He is one of my favorites, though, to whom I turn again and again for provocation, amusement, and to be challenged.
"Once the decision has been made, close your ear even to the best counterargument: sign of a strong character. Thus an occasional will to stupidity."
(Beyond Good and Evil, Epigrams/Interludes, 107 - trans. Walter Kaufmann).
October 29, 2004 | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry:
https://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d834205dc953ef00e5501e3e688833
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Once you've decided ...:
Comments
Just curious - your Rand-ian philisophy come
back to haunt while using "Jane Galt" - been reading any of her books lately?
Just thought I'd point that out... :)
Posted by: MBO at Oct 29, 2004 6:51:54 PM
I'm more into Raymond Chandler, 1948 -- they're all just politicians.
Having voted for Kerry, I will hope until election day, and if my hopes are realized, I'll sharpen the knife once more. Superior baloney, but baloney all the same.
If my hopes aren't realized...
Posted by: roger at Oct 29, 2004 7:59:11 PM
I like the quote, Paul. A sufficiently obscure cousin to Emerson's overplayed "foolish consistency". I think the key being, in both cases, that if you cannot recognize when your adamance constitutes a "will to stupidity", when you are being inconsistent, or when consistency truly is foolish, you should be barred from abusing Bartlett's (and from holding high political office).
Posted by: Aaron at Nov 2, 2004 5:12:24 AM